What Really Happened After Texas Roadhouse Server Livy Took a Risk With a Carrie Underwood Cover on American Idol

Livy, a 22-year-old server from West Virginia, made a lasting impression on American Idol with an audition full of charm, humor, and powerhouse vocals. Working at Texas Roadhouse, she’s known for singing to guests on their birthdays—and that’s exactly where her journey toward national attention began.

Before she even sang a note, Livy brought her workplace spirit into the audition room. Greeting the judges like restaurant guests, she offered up Texas Roadhouse rolls, cinnamon butter, and peanuts while playfully taking their “drink orders.” Her energetic introduction had the judges laughing, especially when she sang a cheeky margarita line directly to Luke Bryan.

Livy shared that she often performs at her job, leading the restaurant’s signature “Texas-sized yee-haw” birthday celebrations. Videos of her singing “Happy Birthday” went viral on TikTok, building momentum that eventually inspired her to audition for the show.

The fun didn’t stop there. Livy—whose full name is Olivia Spino—told Luke Bryan that her mom, Maria, is one of his biggest fans and jokingly warned him to prepare himself. The lighthearted moment added to the already lively atmosphere.

Dressed in a red button-up shirt, black jacket, black jeans, and bright red sneakers, Livy then delivered a passionate cover of Carrie Underwood’s “Love Wins.” Her powerful vocals filled the room, but after the first run, Luke Bryan asked Carrie if Livy might be pushing too hard.

Carrie offered thoughtful feedback, suggesting Livy ease up and allow more emotion to shine through. Taking the advice, Livy sang the chorus again with a softer, more controlled tone—instantly transforming the performance. Carrie praised the emotional depth of the second attempt and voted yes, encouraging Livy to continue showing both her powerful and gentle sides.

Luke agreed, noting that Livy’s talent didn’t require her to force the performance. Lionel Richie, joking that he was “full” from the snacks she brought, also gave her a heartfelt yes, calling her a sweetheart with something truly magical in her voice.

With three yeses, Livy earned her golden ticket to Hollywood Week in Music City. Beyond the milestone moment, her mother also got the chance to meet Luke Bryan—an unforgettable highlight for the family.

Texas Roadhouse Server Livy; Photo Courtesy of American Idol via ABC

Now headed to Hollywood, Livy is ready to prove she belongs. As she proudly declared after her audition, it’s her turn to hold that golden ticket—and she’s prepared to show the world exactly what she can do.

New episodes of American Idol air Monday nights on ABC and stream the next day on Hulu.

Leave a Comment